CalledToBetter

The Richest Man in Babylon by George Clason: An Honest Review

Two corrections before the review, because the previous version got both wrong.

This is not a Christian book. The old post called it “this essential Christian finance book,” said it was “rooted in biblical money principles,” and claimed a “focus on tithing.” George S. Clason published The Richest Man in Babylon in 1926 as a series of pamphlets for banks and insurance companies. There is no Scripture in it and no Christian framework.

The edition matters. The listing this post points to is an abridged edition, which the old review never mentioned. The full text is short to begin with, and it is old enough to be widely available free or cheap. Check what you are ordering before you pay for a condensed version of a book you could read whole.

What the book actually teaches

It is a set of parables set in ancient Babylon, built around Arkad, the richest man in the city, explaining how he got there. The advice is simple and it has aged well:

Pay yourself first, meaning save a tenth of everything you earn before you spend any of it. Live on less than you make. Put your savings to work rather than letting them sit. Do not gamble on schemes you do not understand. Own your home. Insure against disaster. Keep learning your trade so your earning power grows.

That is essentially the whole book, dressed in robes and sandals. It is good advice, it is a century old, and it works.

The tithing confusion, and why it matters

This is worth being precise about, because the old review got it backwards.

Clason’s famous rule is to keep a tenth for yourself. Tithing is giving a tenth away. Those are opposite motions with the same number attached, and conflating them is not a small slip. Clason’s book is about accumulation. He is not against generosity, but it is not what he is teaching, and the biblical case for giving does not come from Arkad.

Take the saving discipline from this book. Get your theology of generosity somewhere else.

The honest limitation

The parable format makes it memorable and also makes it thin. Every character who follows the rules prospers, which is how parables work but not how life always works. A man can save faithfully and still get wiped out by a medical bill or a layoff. Clason’s Babylon has no such thing, and a reader in a genuinely hard season may find the confidence grating.

The language is also 1926 pastiche antiquity, which some readers enjoy and others find tiresome.

The previous review additionally quoted a review team discussing their budgets. There was no team. Removed.

Who should read it

A man early in his working life who has never been taught the basics. Someone who needs the fundamentals in a form he will actually remember, since the stories stick better than a spreadsheet. Good for a teenager.

Skip it if you already save consistently and want something more advanced, or if you were looking for a Christian treatment of money, which this has never been.

The Richest Man in Babylon on Amazon